Need a book? Engineering books recommendations...
Re: higher loads or better details.[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
- To: seaint(--nospam--at)seaint.org
- Subject: Re: higher loads or better details.
- From: ErnieNSE(--nospam--at)aol.com
- Date: Fri, 4 Sep 1998 23:05:02 EDT
I've been reading arguments about which is best....higher loads, continuous path or better details? I don't think there is a correct choice. The answer should be all or none or a little of each. I think it is a matter of engineer's judgement based on education, skills,experience, etc. Those who prefer higher loads might have had a bad experience(or heard it from somebody else, or read a book about it or leartned about it in a seminar) about poor performance of a project even if there are a lot of good details(by the way, how do you rate if a detail is bad or good? .......... JUDGEMENT!!!!) The same thing is true for those who prefer better details....or continuous path. How about structural observation???????No matter how high your design loads are or how complete your load path is or how good your details are........if the contractor do not build it per your plans(assuming that your plans are complete, concise and precise), the structure is still inferior. How about the owner's or user's maintenance of the structure? Neglect can cause an excellently designed buiding to collapse. There are a lot of other factors, considerations and conditions that make a good structure(or any product for that matter). It is the right combination of these factors that make them good or bad. But it is unquatifiable and there is no exact formula for the best combination. Sometimes, a .1% mistake out of a 99.9% good job makes the whole job poor, not the average of the .1% and 99.9%. Let's use our judgement and do the best we can out there. By the way, reading all these experiences, preferences and excesses by other engineers increased my experience already and I will surely consider all of these in my JUDGEMENT when I design my next project. Ernie Natividad
- Prev by Subject: higher loads or better details.
- Next by Subject: Re: higher loads or better details.
- Previous by thread: higher loads or better details.
- Next by thread: Re: higher loads or better details.