To the steel detailing mailing list...
I'll bet some of you detailers and/or fabricators have some experience in
this area. I'll appreciate your feedback and (assuming the engineers are
interested), will forward it back to the engineers' list.
Fountain E. Conner, P.E.
Gulf Breeze, Fl. 32561
> From: Garry Frederick <GFREDERICK(--nospam--at)HNTB.com>
> To: 'seaint(--nospam--at)seaint.org'
> Subject: Erecting Steel Braced Frames with Bolted Connections
> Date: Thursday, June 24, 1999 4:40 PM
> > What facilitates erecting steel braced frames with bearing bolted
> > connections when using standard holes whose diameters are 1/16-inch
> > greater than their matching bolts? Recently a 22-foot by 22-foot by
> > 100-foot high tower whose X-braces crossed at the mid-span of beams at
> > alternating floors went up poorly because the holes in the braces did
> > match the holes in the connecting plates on the columns and beams. Even
> > after reaming some of the mismatched holes to accommodate the next
> > diameter of bolts, more than 120 mismatched holes remained. What
> > enabled the tower to be erected within tolerances per section 7.11
> > Tolerances of the 1986 AISC Code of Standard Practice was by welding
> > instead of bolting the braces to the beams.
> > What may have caused the bolt holes to be so mismatched? The base
> > for the columns had been positioned within the erection tolerance of
> > or minus 1/8-inch of the design elevation per section 7.6 Bearing
> > of the AISC Code of Standard Practice. The wide-flanged beams, columns
> > braces had been milled and fabricated within the tolerances per ASTM
> > Does the accumulation of mill, fabrication and erection tolerances
> > preclude using bolted braces with standard round holes unless extra
> > measures are taken beyond standard construction? Do base plates need to
> > exactly at the design elevation with no plus or minus 1/8-inch
> > Do bolted braced frames need to be assembled in the shop by the
> > to insure ease of erection by the erector? Does the contractor always
> > the option of welding the braces?