Ken - this is a very frightening. Were you insured? If you were, would not
having insurance, in your opinion, resulted in you being dropped from the
Dennis Wish PE
From: KTarlow(--nospam--at)aol.com [mailto:KTarlow(--nospam--at)aol.com]
Sent: Monday, February 28, 2000 12:30 PM
Subject: Re: WOOD: Lateral Design / Link to Testi
I was once sued. I performed a deign on some condominiums in 1988. The
units sit on type 1 garage. The column spacings were 35' in one direction
and 40' in the other. I designed beams and one way slabs to support the
The contractor reviewing my drawings asked me to redesign it as a rebar flat
slab (he wouldn't let me post tension the deck) and I refused. I believe
there is no way that flat slab will work with those spans.
I was fired from the Job. A new Engineer was hired to take over. Later the
Architect and the Developer got into an argument that resulted in a 21 day
trial. I was named in the suite.
It took $10,000 to get out of the suite. Clearly I did nothing wrong.
The end result is that I was out $10.000. The Architect was paid for his
services (he won his suite), The Engineer who took over the job (during his
work he changed and signed the architects plans actually causing the law
suite) was paid (his fee more than 5 times my fee) and, the home owners who
are now experiencing the effects of the long term deflection of the slabs
have doors and windows that won't close and etc.. They have initiated a law
suite, I have been named again, but the statute of limitations have run on
the Architect and the other Engineer, and never had any liability.
The lawyers were all paid. The people who were free of any wrong doing were
out the most money.
I would like to see a candidate who would reform our tort system.
PS that Engineer is still out there