Return to index: [Subject] [Thread] [Date] [Author]

Re: Exposure D Wind/ People in authority

[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
>The problem, as I see it, is the whole process by which we abdicate our
>authority as specialists in our business to people other than
>ourselves.  We begin this process when we create building codes meant
>to be adopted as law.  This process is governed by "the few" for the
>"benefit" of "the many."
Another take on this. Any design code is intended to be a brief, ideally 
unambiguous, summary of prudent engineering practice as reflected by 
field service. (We can argue whether the building codes are or not--I 
claim that's what they are intended to be.). No engineer abdicates 
responsibility by resorting to the validated experience of other 
engineers. In fact these engineers _are_ the specialists. We're not 
abdicating anything by relying on our peers.

And a building code which hasn't the force of law is pretty much useless. 
It pretty much allows anyone to do anything, and when it kills someone, 
back out by saying, 'No one said I had do do it that way.' When 
manufacturers or builders will stand beside a pile of wreckage and say, 
out loud, for the record, 'Yeah, we built this, it was our work and it 
killed people. We screwed up big time, and we're gonna make restitution,' 
we won't need the force of law. Until then...

You want a good example? The steamboat Sultana blew up in 1865 near 
Memphis, killing more than 1500 people, mostly Federal troops on their 
way home from Confederate POW camps. No one, unless you count the 
soldiers who died, took the rap--not the owners, not the Army, not the 
crew, not the people who were supposed to make sure the boiler was safe 
(The suspected cause was a faulty patch put on a boiler after an argument 
over whether the boiler needed major work after a low water excursion 
caused a bulge.). After a few years, when the ruckus died down, the dead 
passengers _did_ get a nice bronze plaque. 
No laws--no accountability.  

Christopher Wright P.E.    |"They couldn't hit an elephant from
chrisw(--nospam--at)        | this distance"   (last words of Gen.
___________________________| John Sedgwick, Spotsylvania 1864)