Subject: RE: HSS vs. TS Properties For Design (WAS: Re: Copyright Infringement)
From: "David I. Ruby, P.E." <druby(--nospam--at)rubyusa.com>
Date: Thu, 11 Jan 2001 10:10:28 -0500
Davis, LRFD is only the ASD with mystic factors. What benefit to the
industry? the profession? The load is increased by 1.4 or more, the results
are then factored down, Actually the original LRFD factors were developed
to insure the same results as ASD; in order that the method would be
accepted more readily.
The method has been actively advanced by AISC since 1986, continuously
taught in seminars and endorsed by all university Civil Engineering
programs; Why has it not been accepted????? Can it be that it does not suit
the needs of the design profession nor the steel industry.
There is value in knowing the failure mechanism of your structure, but it is
hard to imagine that multiplying loads by factors then applying phi factors
to predict the ultimate load capacity gives anyone a better feel with a
material that is routinely furnished to yields 10% higher that advertised. I
understand that this is of concern in high seismic areas and the procedure
maybe of great value their; but try to apply the method to the design of
crane runways, industrial buildings and stacks where serviceability is the
prime design criteria.
David I. Ruby, S.E.
From: Bill Polhemus [mailto:bpolhem(--nospam--at)swbell.net]
Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2001 7:53 AM
Subject: HSS vs. TS Properties For Design (WAS: Re: Copyright
One "problem" with this, I think, is that there are "new" design
to go along with those new dimensional properties in the HSS Manual. These
specifications are LRFD only (with which, as I've said many times here, I
NO problem, but which give others massive heartburn!)
These specifications are sufficiently more in-depth that I think one would
to use them rather than try to apply Ninth Edition AISC-ASD provisions.
I have never really delved into it, but I guess it might be possible to
"convert" the design specification provisions to the antiquated,
ancient, creaking and threadbare ASD method, if one were so inclined.
Davis Parsons wrote:
> They are completely listed in the HSS Connections Manual