RE: AISC II (the facts)[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
- To: "'seaint(--nospam--at)seaint.org'" <seaint(--nospam--at)seaint.org>
- Subject: RE: AISC II (the facts)
- From: Charlie Carter <carter(--nospam--at)aiscmail.com>
- Date: Mon, 23 Apr 2001 09:00:06 -0500
> Are the equations in the
> AISC Specifications protected?
Yes. See the copyright page in the front of the specification. When you buy a copy, though, I think our understanding is that you are buying the right to use the information for yourself. The issue we're discussing centers more on the subsequent use of the information you bought by others who may not have.
I think my idea of pairing the AISC Manual and the AISC Shapes Database is the way to make the argument moot, since everyone buys a Manual.
> Does AISC claim copyright
> protection of bolt design values?
No, but RCSC does (well, RCSC holds the copyright on the RCSC Specification, anyway). AISC is just the publisher in that case.
> If I use them in a spreadsheet, then give
> the spreadsheet to someone, am I liable?
Say I buy design drawings and specifications for a building from you. After I have my building, is it OK with you if I re-draw the drawings and re-type the specifications you sold to me so I have them in electronic form? Say a friend of mine likes my building so much that he wants one too. Can I give him copies of the re-drawn drawings and re-typed specifications for his use? Say we find out that a LOT of people like our buildings. Can we set up a business of our own to sell the re-drawn drawings and re-typed specifications so that everyone can have one of these nifty buildings? Would you hold me liable?
My guess is you'd answer: Yes. No. No. Yes.
> Are properties of reinforcing steel
> protected by either ACI or CRSI?
> Does AITC claim copyright protection
> of all the data in their manual
> that I am unable to calculate
> myself? What about the model
> building codes? Are their data protected?
I do not know. Better check with them directly.
> It has always been my understanding
> that one could quote
> from a text if credit is given.
> Has this become illegal?
I think your understanding is correct. But I also think there are limits on what constitutes fair use. Our policy is to obtain written permission, just to be sure.
- Prev by Subject: Re: AISC II (the facts)
- Next by Subject: Re: AISC II (the facts)
- Previous by thread: Re: AISC II (the facts)
- Next by thread: RE: AISC II (the facts)