Need a book? Engineering books recommendations...

Return to index: [Subject] [Thread] [Date] [Author]

RE: arched roof wind theory

[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
My theory (no research):
As wind passes over an arched roof, beyond the perimiter, there are no edges or sudden changes in pitch, nor obstructions, that would cause a localized pressure difference. This is compared to a roof with a ridge or hip. In Bernoulli-esque terms, this would be uniform or undisturbed flow over the surface of the roof, so that it would recieve a lower, more constant uplift pressure, so that MWFRS loads could be used rather then C and C.
Also, due to the small percentage of these types of roofs being constructed (in the US), there has probably been little demand for more research and testing on this type of roof system, versus gable and ridge roofs, and hip roofs, which are on 98% (out of my a$$) of houses and other residential type structures.
Now, I have said this before, but can I vote "YES" now on more funding for canopy roofs and overhang roofs, like those on every gas station, strip mall, grocery store, school, etc. in the friggin US??? 
Side note: Down near the east coast, central FL, a rest area off I-95 had little noticeable hurricance damage, except for the pre-fab aluminium canopies which many had no roof and had racked. Some soffit damage to the main building with 16' CMU walls, that is about it (standing seam roof). Ok, now I will pat myself on the back because I did the structural eng on the main buildings, but that is not my point... Do you think anyone will take that company and their engineer to task on the design? As far as I know we had no winds down there near the design speed of 130 mph.....
Andrew Kester, PE
Structural Engineering Consultant
Lake Mary, FL
C 407-324-6255