Bill Polhemus wrote:
Free Enterprise/Free Trade is both inevitable and expansive. EVERYONE
benefits. There's no such thing as "trade" that benefits only one side,
or is extremely lopsided. If both sides don't benefit sufficiently, the
People here who whine about "jobs for America" are showing complete
ignorance about economics. This is the sort of ignorance that
politicians capitalize on as they pander for votes as "protectionists."
This means both the so-called "paleo-cons" (who are somewhat "paleo" in
that they have been around since before the U.S. was the U.S., but they
AREN'T conservative, at least in the current sense of the term) and the
radical pro-Unionist liberal Democrats.
I will NEVER forget how in the late 70s and through the 80s, "Japan,
Inc." was supposed to "bury" us. Hm, wonder whatever happened with
that? Got a clue?
Here is a simplified summary of your assumption - in real terms:
The trouble with your argument is that you focus on the low price of
the end product, and refuse to recognize the sacrifice that American
workers have to make. Let's put it in terms of engineering fee's. If
the architect that owed you $600.00 decided that he will no longer give
you work because he can inflate his profit margin by outsourcing
engineering to countries where he pays $3.50 per hour to obtain the
same work that you provide? The result of this becomes obvious:
- Everyone benefits from the lower prices obtained by companies
like Walmart who outsource their labor for the packaging of goods and
the assembly processes to countries where wages result in higher
earnings and lower prices here In the US.
- I really don't understand how you can throw around labels like
"Paleo-cons" or "Radical Pro-Unionist Liberal Democrats" or
"protectionists". The only word here that I can relate to is
Protectionist and unless we are dealing with fair competition, then I
am proud to be a protectionist.
A recent article in the Washington Post notes the dissatisfaction that
Americans have with IBM (and other companies) who outsources their
technical support to New Delhi. The article is from the March 7-13 2005
edition "An Earful of Ire from Americans" by Rama Lakshimi (page 18).
Nearly 25% of the callers are dissatisfied with the service. The
technicians are trained and they are polite, but there is a language
problem as the technician does not understand the idioms we use daily.
On a side note, when I threatened to buy my computers from another
source, a Dell Customer Service Supervisor almost laughed at me and
told me I had not choice as there were no tech companies that were not
outsourcing jobs to India and laying off workers in the US because of
the obvious earnings gain. Back to IBM! The callers were even told by
the technician that they were of Indian decent but that they were
calling from the United States (when in fact they were answering calls
in New Delhi). They made up simple American names "Tim", "Jim", "Juli"
etc. The told the caller they were in the state of Washington and their
employer went as far as to post an electronic board in their office
that indicated the weather, time, current sporting events and records
that existed in order to try and convince the caller that they were in
the U.S. - but the problem was most Americans did not buy the lie.
Again, on the side - I received a bill from a doctor and when I called
about the bill (which was 40% higher than the previous statement that
the insurance company was suppose to pay) I found that my local doctors
were outsourcing their billing and bookkeeping services.
- You can not make your mortgage payment because of the loss of
- You are forced to compete against lower fees because nobody
really cares about protecting US Jobs - if it is a larger company with
investors, they only are concerned with earnings and are willing to do
whatever it takes to maximize profits and satisfy investor earnings at
The article states "the outsourcing industry earns $5.1 billion a year
and employs more than 350,000 people, according to the national
Association of Software and Services Companies, and is projected to
grow 40% in the coming year." This figure includes companies such as
"American Express, Sprint, Citibank, General Electric, Ford, Hewlett
Packard Electric, IBM and firms that process U.S. tax returns and
So, now Bill you are saying that American's should sacrifice their jobs
doing the same work that will be outsourced to another country for
$5.60 per hour. Now assume that you are dealing with an educated
engineer in India who is capable of providing the same quality of work
you do but the Architect need only pay $5.60 per hour while he bills
his client 10% of construction cost for the project. If you are worried
about errors, in California, the Architect can not be litigated for
outsourcing and receiving inadequate results unless there is a failure
that results in the loss of human life and then the Architect is the
first in line to be sued. Do you think that International tribunals
will win a case against a 3rd world nation for doing a sub-standard
design job even though they received a permit for the work?
- $5,100,000,000 / 350,000 people = $14,571.43 per person average.
- $14,571.43 / (52 weeks * 40 hours) = $11.21 per hour per person
gross company earnings.
- Assume the company makes 50% of the income (American engineering
firms usually bill at 2.5 times cost, but lets assume this is billed
only as 2 times earnings). Each employee is working for around $5.60
per hour. If they bill at 2.5 times cost then the employees average
$4.48 per hour.
- However, management earns more than phone techs and this average
needs to be adjusted.
To put it in perspective, you fail to recognize the sacrifice of those
I think you need to get your facts correct, because the next job lost
to outsourcing might be yours. If you are lucky to slip by the think of
your children and their children as to how difficult it will be for
them to have ownership in this country when the upper income community
is benefiting from the increased earnings on their investment without
ever getting their hands dirty.
- Can no longer keep up payments for the mortgage on their home
- Automatically becomes a risk as they try to pay off credit card
loans by paying only minimums because they lost their job.
- Now your family is forced to buy the lower priced goods that come
from China because you no longer have a choice - you can't afford to
spend any more for toilet tissue.
- Your personal information including credit card debt and tax
returns are now in a country that does not recognize your privacy and
can, at their discretion, distribute your personal information or sell
Finally, other areas in the world are being prepared for low cost
labor. What India and China does not understand is that if these
companies can walk out of the United States to find cheaper labor, they
can walk out of India and China when their economy escalates to a
standard of living competitive to us. They will fall in the same pit
when jobs are lost and the "security" that you expected in a job is now
in the pocket of a "rich conservative elite."
Dennis S. Wish, PE
California Professional Engineer
Structural Engineering Consultant
760.564.0884 (office - fax)
This e-mail is intended
to be delivered
only to the named addressee(s) and may contain information that is
confidential and proprietary. If this information is received by anyone
other than the named addressee(s), the recipient(s) should immediately
notify the sender by e-mail and promptly delete the transmitted
material from your computer and server. In no event shall this material
be read, used, stored, or retained by anyone other than the named
addressee(s) without the express written consent of the sender or the