Return to index: [Subject] [Thread] [Date] [Author]

RE: Foundation Pinning

[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
I'm involved in ongoing projects of this type.  To be candid, it the only time I've done "hired gun" type work.  Based on my experience, I'll be better ahead, and happier, if I work for the lawyers than try to actually solve these problems.
The variation in design is incredible.  An example:
Contractors Engineer  - 11 piers, minor cosmetic damage
Insurance Engineer - 42 piers, major cosmetic damage
Structural Engineer - Consider tearing down and rebuilding, it may be cheaper
Geotechnical Engineer for Owner (me) - As Above from structural engineer or 48 piers, and a lots of cosmetic repair. 
This was a residence less than 18 months old and had cracks in the floor slab about 1 1/2 inches wide at three locations, the rear exterior wall was rotating out, but at least most of the doors would still close.  For some reason, I can't get anyone to explain to me how they rationalize this, but only 2 #5 bars were installed in the foundation and floor slab, in the bottom of the foundation around the perimeter and in the thickened section for interior walls.
On the plus side, the Lawyer has some home builder clients, (not involved with the above), who now do some actual geotechnical work, and ask for recommendations on steel and such.  Don't know whether to be happy for the work or afraid of the litigation potential.
-----Original Message-----
From: GSKWY(--nospam--at) [mailto:GSKWY(--nospam--at)]
Sent: Monday, May 09, 2005 6:53 AM
To: seaint(--nospam--at)
Subject: Re: Foundation Pinning

I did not get the sense this was a highly engineered design.  It was warranty work,  and the warranty provider had an engineer that reviewed the contractor's proposals, but I think only one of the three contractors actually used an engineer when coming up with an estimate.
It was complicated by the fact that the warranty only covered the actual foundation work,  it did not pay to restore the landscaping or to repair floor finishes damaged in the course of the repair work.  Or at least  this was the owners' understandings,  based on prior experience of other people in the subdivision who had the work done. 
So while on the one hand, an owner probably would want a lot of work done,  to make sure they had solved the problem, beyond a shadow of a doubt,  on the other hand, this was likely to cost them a lot more than a less extensive repair.
I'm not sure how common this kind of work is in the DC area, but it is common enough for at least three contractors to do it as their only line of work.
Gail Kelley