Need a book? Engineering books recommendations...
Re: CMU Infills[Subject Prev][Subject Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
- To: seaint(--nospam--at)seaint.org
- Subject: Re: CMU Infills
- From: Daniel Popp <drp181(--nospam--at)yahoo.com>
- Date: Mon, 28 Jan 2008 15:58:44 -0800 (PST)
IBC 2006 Section 2106.1 (Masonry - Seismic Design) ..."All masonry walls, unless isolated on three edges from in-plane motion of the basic structural systems, shall be considered to be part of the seismic-force-resisting system"...
MSJC 2002 Section 1.10.2 (Connection to structural frames) "Masonry walls shall not be connected to structural frames unless the connections and walls are designed to resist design interconnecting forces and to accommodate calculated deflections."
MSJC 2002 Section 184.108.40.206.2 (Design of elements that are not part of the lateral force-resisting system) "Masonry partition walls, masonry screen walls and other masonry elements that are not designed to resist vertical or lateral loads, other than those induced by their own mass, shall be isolated from the structure so that vertical and lateral forces are not imparted to these elements. Isolation joints and connectors between these elements and the structure shall be designed to accommodate the design story drift."
Ralph has a very good point: Beware partial-height CMU infill. I had a professor in graduate school who referred to partial-height infill walls as "baby killers". It seems that in some countries, this was (or is) a common type of construction for schools, with windows above the masonry. When an earthquake hits, the inelastic deformation of the column is limited to the portion above the infill, which can lead to collapse. We were shown a picture of a two-story school building that had formerly been three stories. If school had been in session...
From: "Gerard Madden, SE" <gmse4603(--nospam--at)gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, January 28, 2008 12:56:11 PM
Subject: Re: CMU Infills
I think it's sort of taken care of by not having it listed as a recognized LFRS in the structural system tables in the code.
Then there are code provisions about interactions of different systems within a same direction of a building, on different and same lines of resistance, and by story.
It's in there (i.e., you need to model the building...if the infill walls are in contact with moment frames, your model better reflect that), but it just takes digging rather than blatantly saying in Code Commandment #220.127.116.11a "Thou shall not use CMU infill walls in combination with Concrete Moment Frames.
I guess the point is, rather than try to capture every possible system name, the code attempts to say "you can't do this unless..." in more general terms
Designing the frames for forces that will be created due engaging the infill CMU "infill" walls will be expensive. Creating a space between CMU infill walls seems awkward. I wonder why a dangerous issue such as this was not taken care of by any structural code.Alex C. NacionalesSent: Saturday, January 26, 2008 6:38 AMSubject: RE: CMU InfillsI don't recall if there are actual code provisions, but there are certainly FEMA documents that discussion the issue of masonry infill walls in frames and how to retrofit or even design for them. If I recall correctly, the main thing to try to do is leave enough isolation room between the frame and the infill walls to allow the frame to deflect as "desired" without "engaging" the infill wall...OR design the frame for the types of forces that will be created due to "engaging" the infill walls.Regards,ScottAdrian, MI-----Original Message-----
From: Alex C. Nacionales [mailto:anacionales(--nospam--at)insightts.net]
Sent: Friday, January 25, 2008 5:02 PM
Subject: CMU InfillsDear Fellow Engineers,My RC design teacher has taught us has to ignore the effect of CMU infills on a RC frame because they will be crushed during a seismic event. Recent seminars I attended shows that cmu infills interferes with frame action thus attracting more shear. Is there any code provision regarding on how to treat cmu infills in relation with RC frames or steel frames?Your assistance will much appreciated. Thanks.Sincerely,Alex C. Nacionales.
- Re: CMU Infills
- From: Gerard Madden, SE
- Re: CMU Infills
- Prev by Subject: Re: CMU Infills
- Next by Subject: Re: CMU Infills
- Previous by thread: Re: CMU Infills
- Next by thread: Re: CMU Infills